Virgin Islands Looking for Stolen Cars in Arkansas

The Virgin Islands Police Department — a Caribbean island territory with a population of 107,000 — is querying Flock cameras in Rogers, Arkansas, for traffic infractions. Among the search reasons logged:

• Traffic Infraction
• City Planning/Traffic Analysis - test
• Welfare Check
• Larceny/Theft Offenses - Unauthorized use of a vehicle

VIPD appeared in recently imported log files. It’s not uncommon for new agencies to show up, but this may be the first instance of an agency outside the continental US we’ve seen. It raises some interesting questions. First and foremost: why?

It’s always been highly questionable for an agency in, say, Washington to claim that it has any legitimate purpose for querying data from Florida. The Virgin Islands being, well, islands, takes it from “questionable” to “downright ridiculous.”

At least someone in Washington could steal a car or run a red light and flee to Florida. In fact, I’d put money on at least a handful of people having done that or something similar. Is it likely? No. Is it possible? Sure, I guess.

But the argument here would be that someone stole a car in the Virgin Islands, left the plates on, shipped it to the mainland via commercial freight — which presumably checks VINs — and then drove it around Rogers, Arkansas. You couldn’t get that fiction published in a creative writing course.

It’s another instance of Disproportionate by Default.

This is also a department operating under an active Department of Justice consent decree for unconstitutional policing practices.^[1] The combination — a department with documented civil rights problems, plugged into a nationwide surveillance network, running searches with no apparent investigative nexus — is exactly the scenario that audit requirements are supposed to catch.

Flock’s contractual standard limits use to “legitimate public safety and/or business purpose[s]” — a bar so low it’s practically subterranean. And VIPD still managed to limbo under it.

VIPD’s searches were visible to Flock and every network they queried. Each of those 5,000+ receiving agencies claims to audit its incoming queries. Every one of them should have flagged a Caribbean police department searching for traffic infractions on the mainland. None did.